Finishing Techniques

Painted MDF vs. laminated MDF

MDF is a wood-derived product and although it is not the solid wood we all love, it deserves our attention too. Painted or veneered MDF furniture is beautiful, stable and of good quality. An economical alternative to these variants is veneered MDF furniture, also widely available on the market and preferred by many for its low price and wood-like designs. I will try to draw a parallel between these two MDF coating variants, showing the pluses and minuses of each.

MDF veneer is, as the name suggests, a MDF board of various shapes, over which a PVC foil is laid. The foil is glued to the board with special adhesives at high temperatures using membrane presses. The press can follow the contours of the piece, and the foil can also be applied to profiled MDF. The PVC film is thicker or thinner, matt or glossy. It can be coloured, it can have geometric or abstract patterns, it can reproduce the design of the wood, and it can also be 3D (the pores and grain of the wood are reproduced). What a veneer press looks like, sold by WoodMatic, you can see here.

Painted MDF
photo source: alibaba.com

The advantages of using laminated MDF are:

  • low price
  • wide variety of finishes

Disadvantages:

  • lower resistance in environments with high humidity or temperatures
  • there may be problems with peeling of the film at the edges and corners of the panel
Painted MDF
photo source: community.homedepot.com
  • small air bubbles may appear between the foil and the MDF
  • if the foil gets scratched or damaged, it can no longer be repaired
  • models that imitate wood fail to convey the natural warmth of wood
Painted MDF
photo source: cabinetdoorkitchen.com

Painted MDF is obtained by applying layers of primer and coloured enamel to the surface of the processed panels. Painting is done so that the whole board is well covered. 1-2 coats of primer are applied and sanded after drying to obtain a good surface for the coloured enamel.

The final layer, the enamel, can be matt or glossy, coloured in a multitude of colours. Special effects, patinas or other finishes can be applied to increase the value of the furniture. Sometimes, in the case of glossy finishes, 1-2 coats of high gloss clear lacquer can be applied to better protect the colour, for depth and more shine.

Painted MDF
photo source: maplecraftusa.com

The advantages of painted MDF furniture include:

  • much better protection against moisture of the entire panel surface
  • much better resistance to high temperatures
  • any scratches in the film can be repaired
  • using coloured primers and patinas can produce antique-looking finishes, very similar to painted wood

The disadvantages are:

  • higher price
  • longer time to obtain the finished product
  • the natural wood pattern cannot be reproduced. To be more precise, it cannot be easily reproduced, because there are special templates that imitate the design of wood and can be used on paint.

In addition to the advantages outlined above, painted MDF can also be considered a more nature-friendly option. It can also be coated with water-repellent products, a trend that has become increasingly popular in recent times, without reducing the range of colours or finishes.

The materials used for painting - polyurethane, water-based, UV-curable - are products that make furniture much more resistant to moisture in the kitchen or bathroom and are very resistant to high temperatures, eliminating the risk of the film cracking when the furniture is near a heat source (stove, oven, stove).

Painted MDF
photo source: kraftmaid.com

Manufacturers of painted MDF furniture can also use machines or finishing lines to finish wood and not only MDF. We know that the market is constantly changing and having more versatile finishing possibilities that can be quickly adapted to market requirements is a real advantage.

Painted MDF offers the possibility of a wide variety of finishes. We have already told you about my MDF kitchenwhose antiqued finish I did myself. In the case of the foil you are limited to the existing pattern. Indeed, there are a lot of patterns, but you have to have those foils and I doubt any manufacturer chooses to have hundreds of foil patterns. With paints you can play around and get a lot of finishes using a white primer, a few colors and 2-3 patinas.

Choosing painted MDF furniture offers some advantages that can sometimes outweigh the price difference. And the availability of finishing machines allows manufacturers to adapt much more quickly to demand. Sticking only to the possibility of applying foil to MDF when trends, market requirements and times are constantly and rapidly changing is a rather risky choice.

In addition, the following can be consideredcoating MDF with powder paints which comes with a number of benefits that will make the finishing system far superior to existing ones.

About the author

Mihaela Radu

Mihaela Radu is a chemical engineer but has a great passion for wood. She has been working in the field for more than 20 years, wood finishing being what defined her during this period. She gained experience working in a research institute, in her own company, as well as in a multinational. She wants to continuously share her experience with those who have the same passion - and more.

28 comments

Add a comment

Leave a Reply to Mihaela Radu Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  • Hello,

    I was convinced that moulded MDF was the best, so I was told, it is obvious that I was wrong, now I can only pray that my custom-made kitchen with moulded MDF fronts will last me as long as possible and that I won't end up in a situation where I get hand-painted MDF from moulded MDF. I was told that only the fronts are moulded because of the high cost. After all moulded MDF is not so good for the kitchen, where it is hot, steamy, damp. Thanks a lot for the info, from now on I'll take a better look at MDF furniture and maybe for what I need in the kitchen I'll choose painted wood cabinets or shelves... Have a nice day!

  • Hello, if I may, I would like to add an advantage to painted MDF: the finishing films obtained from film-forming materials (varnish, paint, enamel, primer) considerably reduce the emission of formaldehyde from MDF, due to its structure (it consists of several layers). Each layer applied subsequently reduces the porosity of the previous layer by 50 %.

  • Hello,
    Thank you for this very well put together article in which you have detailed the differences between the 2 types of finishes as well as you could. You have just simplified the presentation process for us as well.

    • It depends on the nature of the paint. If you want to apply over two-component polyurethane paint or water-based paint, you can, but you have to sand beforehand so that the varnish has adhesion. Sanding is done on the day of application. It cannot be applied over nitro or alkyd paint (based on linseed oil and petroleum solvents).

      • If the foil has peeled off in places and curled in areas exposed to heat can it be glued and with what?
        If not, can the foil be peeled off and the MDF reused for relaminating or painting?
        Thanks in advance!

        • Hello.
          If the foil is thermoplastic you can also glue it by ironing with an iron (put a cloth or a blanket on the foil, so that only heat reaches the foil). You can use polyurethane or hot melt adhesives because they don't react instantly and this gives you time to do a good job (about these adhesives, but also others that can be used in DIY projects, find information in the link below). You need to stretch the foil well and remove the air between it and the MDF board.
          If the foil has come loose in places it can be peeled off the entire surface. When you pull it off, try heating the contact area between the foil and the board with a hair dryer. The MDF is sanded after the foil has been removed and can be re-sanded (if there is a press) or painted. Polyurethane paints are recommended because they are resistant.
          All the best!
          https://revistadinlemn.ro/2018/07/17/5-tipuri-de-adezivi-pentru-proiecte-de-bricolaj/

          Don't forget to subscribe to the printed Wood Magazine! For only 58 lei/year you can find out news in the field, discover craft ideas or trade secrets. We remind you that the content in the printed magazine is different from the one on the website. Details in the link below. 
          Thank you!https://revistadinlemn.ro/product/abonament-revista-din-lemn/

      • Hello Mrs Mihaela.
        Can you point out a very glossy varnish to be applied to the pale casing, I mean the inside as it would be much easier to maintain and easier to sanitize with hot water and soap, frequently with sanitary alcohol specifically? I myself don't like commercially available mixed cleaning products, so I'm going with the doctor's recommendation using the two shown above. I'm also thinking about the inside of all the drawers in a house exposed to street dust by locating the building close to the street, anything you do gathers and as it annihilates it the scented soap doesn't annihilate anything. But I've worn myself out scrubbing the inside of drawers with soap and rinsing them afterwards, so I'd prefer to switch strictly to rubbing alcohol, quickly, once a month. Then reading what Mrs Liudmila wrote about emissions, I'm thinking that we still don't know what kind of furniture materials would and wouldn't emit harmful emissions to us, so it occurs to me that maybe a slightly thinner varnish could be applied with the help of - by chance I got on the net - a famous little electric paint sprayer that has an adjustable nozzle, i.e. it could be gradually turned off/adjusted. Now, I'm thinking with regret about the melacard furniture that could be easily sanitized. Where did it disappear to? It seems that even 71 euro/sqm for infill can still be money wasted in the kitchen, I think that for the casing it would cost a lot more to apply lacquer in the factory, then no one deals with the inside of the drawers in the furniture previously purchased by someone, they all deal with what they want to sell now.
        I would thank you from the bottom of my heart for this information.
        Let's be healthy.

        • Hello.
          The most alcohol-resistant varnishes are those with hardening (polyurethane, acrylic, polyester varnishes, etc.). What I don't understand is why you want it to be glossy since you are using it indoors? Gloss is picky and over time will not look good.
          Lacquers without high chemical resistance (nitrocellulose) will fade from alcohol (lose gloss and transparency).
          The problem with lacquering can be lack of adhesion. If the furniture is made of glossy melamine chipboard or with a very smooth surface it is difficult to apply varnish because it does not stick to the backing. To increase adhesion, the surface should be sanded which spoils the appearance.
          I think you can do it much more simply. The melamine surfaces of chipboard are alcohol resistant, so you don't need lacquer to sanitise the insides of drawers. In my opinion, lacquering more will complicate it.
          And I recommend washing furniture with soap and water or water and dishwashing detergent. It's the most effective and easiest way to degrease it. Regardless of how the furniture is finished. The important thing is that the washing is done with a squeezed cloth or sponge and at the end it is well wiped and wiped.
          For more information on emissions from wood chips (formaldehyde) or finishing products (VOCs - volatile organic compounds), see the links below.
          All the best!
          https://revistadinlemn.ro/2017/10/30/emisia-de-formaldehida-placilor-derivate-din-lemn-un-subiect-mereu-fierbinte/
          https://revistadinlemn.ro/2018/11/09/ce-inseamna-cov-de-pe-eticheta-lacurilor-si-vopselelor-si-cum-ne-afecteaza-emisia-lor/

          • Thank you kindly for your kindness in replying.
            You see, I don't know chemistry like the specialists.
            My father once had a cupboard that was lacquered and could be washed quickly and easily without being affected by soapy water. I washed it for decades without the appearance being somehow distorted. We've also been flooded by neighbors and it stayed ok. What kind of varnish was that as it was a narrow palette in those years, the kind that didn't hold water that you could see the splashes and the kind that rebounded! I doubt that waterproof varnish would have needed UV to dry, or the technology needed for the MDF version that someone specified would be extremely expensive. But today I don't know how to make something so durable, on a large scale and not even used for interior finishing if it's used outside at all, but I'm not as informationally savvy as you! It's, it's a nostalgia of mine. Towards something like this I would tend towards a small Bonanta library with a very good-looking exterior, which I've become emotionally attached to but which has drawers with a plywood (I think it's called pfl) whose surface takes over time, and reacts to water, tends to swell, fades colour and becomes somewhat dusty even if you scrub a little with soap, especially when you pick it up with a damp cloth. Unfortunately it wasn't the export series where it didn't leave the quality to be desired, it was just after the `90s when they were making it snappy with everything inside and it requires correction, support. There I would like to understand what varnish I could apply and be waterproof. You have offered multiple options that have me confused. I have specified that I prefer gloss, but of all of them, which one could it be? I would like you to specify exactly if you know so much, I would then know it is ok and I would trust it. When you have time, it's not urgent, I'd do it around summer. I'll also answer your question about wanting to have glowing varnish in the pale case too as it's deep, I see worse on matte in the depth of the case and in semi-darkness; I may be the perfectionist scales, but I don't yet have a lighting system inside that turns on when I open the door (maybe I'll give ideas for a deal! for pretentious people with a hand, a category to which I don't belong) I also have another housewife, my father who when you don't see him intervenes inopportunely and uninvited and I have nothing to do to him, I discover after the "intervention" that there is chocolate cream or something else there and he doesn't remember what he did on the intention that later he will eat what he put there, but that's how it is with them from an age and besides I LIKE to shine, it gives the feeling of freshness, of real cleanliness which gives me comfort inside and I like to rinse with plenty of water, fast, you can directly under the jet of the tap drawers, removable countertops, how easy to clean without them inside and it goes fast and comes out correctly. Then I don't like to scrub to rinse, I have the feeling that it's still not ok 100%, that it's still partial rinsing, why do I keep scrubbing and changing sponge, rag, yuck, when I can go directly under the jet what can be there fast as not to affect, and if it's varnish to isolate water / moisture is perfect! I used to wash in my youth and the windows put in the tub to be on all sides well scrubbed under the shower jet and soaped and showered, today it doesn't work like that anymore. And it used to go very quickly and was really clean. The smell of clean was my reward. But back then I only had 3 windows, today I have too many and the new kind doesn't allow it, but it doesn't require as much work as the wooden ones, nor do you risk hurting your fingers like the wooden ones if you do it fast. What to do, the scales are typical, I also think I have no patience to imitate dry rinsing, it gives me the feeling of an anus against nature, I prefer directly under the jet, the water flows hard and carries everything, scrub with the rinsing brush f. fast and it stays perfect and goes fast and you have finished quickly much of the house and you get the maximum, you are heading towards hygiene. And thanks again for pointing out what I would need, that's me, that's how I'm used to it, I like to spend my time as I like it, I give myself plenty of time, I don't waste it on drawers, it has to go fast, others go into the cosmos, dear lady, we to rinse with rags which also require cleaning afterwards or with interior furniture sponges? Yours sincerely.

          • The varnish you refer to is polyester. It is very durable and glossy, but impossible to apply at home. To apply the varnish you need to mix it with accelerator and catalyst. If these two products come into contact, it explodes. In the factory, half the quantity of varnish is mixed with accelerator and half with catalyst and then put together. In the past, they used to make those shiny cabinets with a thick layer of varnish.
            For the inside of the drawers use gloss varnish with hardener (polyurethane or water-based). Ask in specialist or DIY stores.
            All the best!

  • Hello,

    I read the article and understand that painted mdf is better quality for kitchen furniture.
    Can you tell me if there is a major difference between 18mm thick painted mdf and 22mm thick painted mdf?

    Thank you,
    Oana

    • Hello,
      The difference is thickness and weight. If we are talking about the bulkheads, the 22 is stronger than the 18.
      There is no difference between the two categories of mdf in the case of painting.
      All the best!

      • Hello, but how do you know all this? Infilled MDF does not peel if it has the right amount of adhesive. Have you told your customers what happens if they hit a painted door in the corner? Shall I tell you? The paint jumps... Do you know why moulded MDF is not better? Because an MDF paint gun costs 2-3000 lei while a moulding press costs tens of thousands of euros...That's why grapes are sour...When you can't have something you sling mud...

        • As you can see, there are opinions and opinions! What should we think now? Anyway, the prices are not modest today for most of my dear compatriots who cannot afford mdf but e-mag kitchens. But now, we'll think about framing the edges in metal frames that will soon offer satin/printed/antiqued versions and thus we'll create a new way to win customers, we'll launch a novelty on the world market and, we'll have billions in our accounts! We will make a common frame structure with the hinges and come out with something new presented as recommended to the discerning because it gives resistance over time.
          I, first of all, thank the lady who writes here for the helpful education she offers us laymen.
          Then thanks to those who have different opinions.
          Good health and good days.

  • Hello, moulded MDF is much more scratch resistant.We have had moulded MDF in our kitchen for about 10 years and it looks impeccable.Plus as long as you can achieve the same colour from both methods, moulded or painted, painted MDF does not justify the price.

  • Hello,

    I would like to know according to what criteria the thickness of the pvc film used for the mdf is determined and what is the difference in quality between rigid and flexible pvc film.
    Sincerely,

  • Hello! I also have a big dilemma. I'm about to make a new kitchen furniture, new house and I don't know what to choose. I have already talked to 3 people who execute furniture and the opinions were different. Please tell me what to make it out of, as I cook quite a lot. Mdf moulded, mdf painted, glossy or melamine palate. which will resist more to steam, heat, humidity?
    Please give me ub advice. Thank you. Health

    • Hello!
      From my point of view painted MDF is the best. I have kitchen furniture with doors made of MDF painted with polyurethane varnish, the frame is made of melamine chipboard. It's been made for 20 years and holds up very well, despite the fact that I cook quite a bit myself. You have below a link to an article where I talk about this kitchen (there are photos too). I don't recommend making it shiny though because it takes a lot of maintenance. For my kitchen I used a 30 gloss lacquer and it looks great.
      I wish you good health too!
      https://revistadinlemn.ro/2016/07/06/bucataria-mea-antichizata-din-mdf/

  • Hello. in case of exfoliation, can't the skin be re-exfoliated? do the fronts have to be completely redone? esteem

    • Hello!
      Theoretically, it is possible. To re-folder, the surface of the MDF must be thoroughly cleaned of the old layer of adhesive, sanded and stripped so that the foil sits well and no defects appear. It's a lot of work and you'd be hard pressed to find someone to do it. Most prefer to do the door from scratch.

  • Hello,
    Thanks for the article. I'm working on converting a self-driving van (I've also contacted you on tung oil and thanks again for the replies). I've made some furniture doors out of painted plywood but they are not very straight in plan, which is why I switched to mdf doors. Being much heavier, I just made a frame of about 8cm and inside I will put something else, never mind that now. I need to paint them. So far, on the plywood I used hornbach matt white polyurethane paint, single component primer before, there is also primer of the same brand, I find it ok and would still go for it. The question is on the prep side. I've heard of the simpler and better option of spritching (or simple grouting) to close the pores, then fine sanding and painting. What do you think?
    Thank you.

    • Hello!
      This type of putty, also called pore filler putty, is used more on wood or where there is high absorption (in the case of poor quality, loose MDF). If the MDF is of good quality, there is no need for putty. Primer, applied in 2 coats, sanded and then paint applied is sufficient. I don't see the point of putty, especially if you say you are happy with the look of the finish on the plywood.
      If you still use putty, it is very important that the next coat adheres to it. If it doesn't adhere well, there is a risk that the paint will peel off when mechanical shocks or shaking occur.

      • Thank you. I went for the primer version. Today I gave it a coat and as I can see that the fiber has lifted a little I think I chose the right variant. I was afraid that I would have a "hedgehog" hard to get out of smooth.
        I would like to ask you one more question. The doors, both the two back doors and the sliding door, have some kind of glossy pfl boards on the bottom half, I think melamine. Unfortunately it's a bit scratched because the van, although quite new, has been working for me, but it's been carrying goods. I'd like to paint them too but I don't know which paint is more suitable and how to prepare the backing, or if you think it's more ok to roll them, especially as they only have one side visible, but I'm a bit afraid of rolling the back doors, inevitably when I walk around with them open, I might touch them with some objects.
        Incidentally, I recently needed some more 4mm plywood and next to me they only had beech. Hard and strong, that I liked, but heavy, luckily I didn't need much (on the whole van I used alder, ff light but also ff veneer). What I want to say as a curiosity. When cutting with the circular saw it got blackened by the burn, I didn't care because I couldn't see it, but I had some milling slats on the edges of the half-round and it burned there too, even at slower speeds, and the worst thing is that the burn is deep, I took 2-3 mm more and I still didn't get rid of it. It was still laced and would have shown. I gave up on beech and made it out of some alder scraps, no problem. I couldn't quite figure out why it burns, maybe it lights up easier....
        Thank you once again.

        • There is a special primer/insulator that is applied to melamine to increase the adhesion of the paint. I don't know if you can find it in DIY stores, but you can certainly find it at those who sell professional wood paints (Sirca, Sayerlack-Golda, ICA-Lomilux, Renner, Remmers, Milesi, etc). Apply a stain after which you can apply the paint you have already used. After drying, the primer is sanded so that the paint has adhesion.
          Beech is a very good firewood. It ignites easily, burns well and gives off a lot of heat. In this case, the circular saw blade was too fast or not sharp enough and thus overheated, burning the beech wood.

Categories

Subscribe to newsletter

en_USEnglish